Is De Beers the First Step in GDC’s Bigger Plan?

The drama surrounding Anglo American’s sale of De Beers looks set to continue until the deal is done, which is stating the obvious.
Still, the pieces are slowly coming together. Botswana has announced its intention to double its stake to 30%, which President Duma Boko said would make it De Beers’ largest single shareholder. More recently, and somewhat overshadowed by the Botswana headlines, Angola confirmed it intends to acquire 10%. Both moves come as Gareth Penny’s Global Diamond Consortium (GDC) remains the preferred bidder. Namibia appears to be taking a more cautious approach, weighing an investment of 5% to 10%, according to the Windhoek Observer.
That leaves me trying to get my head around what the final shareholder structure might look like.
One possibility is for GDC to serve as a holding company that owns all of De Beers, with the various parties, including the governments, buying into GDC. Botswana would then become the largest single shareholder. That structure could make for a complicated transaction, given that Botswana already owns 15% of De Beers.
The other scenario is for the governments to hold their shares in De Beers directly: 30% for Botswana, 10% for Angola and 5% to 10% for Namibia. That would leave 50% to 55% for the GDC consortium, making it the largest shareholder, although the stake would be shared among its investors. These include Gareth Penny and sightholders Diarough and Grandview Klein, with Richemont, Signet Jewelers and one or two other sightholders potentially joining.
The second option seems more likely and makes more sense. It would also be healthier for the market, allowing the separate entities to check and balance one another. From an industry perspective, though, it could create room for GDC, rather than De Beers, to emerge as the market’s dominant player.
I’m not sure whether that would be a good thing. But it raises the possibility that GDC is being formed not just to acquire De Beers, but to serve as an investment vehicle pursuing opportunities across the diamond and jewelry value chain. The distinction may seem marginal, but it points to a different role for De Beers: not the consortium’s sole purpose, but one part of a broader group of industry players and interests. That is an intriguing prospect.
Read the full November 16 edition of the Pressing Matters Executive Memo here.





Comments